The Founding Fathers wouldn’t want Kavanaugh’s confirmation to continue

canada goose outlet black friday Laurence H. Nixon, rather than routing his opponent, had barely won the presidential election. In that world, when evidence came to light that Nixon had committed impeachable offenses canada goose outlet during his campaign, it would have been plausible to suppose that those offenses were essential to his victory. canada goose uk canada goose outlet black friday

goose outlet canada And the stakes would then have been even higher than they were when, in 1974, the Supreme https://www.pick-canadagoose.com Court was deciding whether buy canada goose jacket Nixon had to comply with a grand jury demand that he deliver up subpoenaed tapes and documents that would prove whether those offenses, and abuses of executive power to cover them up, had indeed been canada goose uk black friday committed by the president. As we all know, United States v. Nixon came out canada goose coats 8 to 0, sounding the death knell of Nixon’s presidency, once he produced the incriminating tapes. goose outlet canada

canada goose outlet in usa A similarly unanimous outcome would be less likely today, however. Observers need look no further than Bush v. canada buy canada goose jacket cheap goose outlet in usa

canada goose outlet new york city If that doesn’t sit right with you, you’re not alone: It didn’t sit right with the framers, either. canada goose outlet new york city

canada goose outlet uk The framers built the Constitution on Canada Goose sale the premise that men aren’t angels, and they canada goose clearance did not trust a president’s nominees to the Supreme Court to be impartial in determining whether he should stay in office. At the Constitutional Convention, Virginia’s George Mason thought judges „surely” ought not Canada Goose Coats On Sale preside over the impeachment trials of presidents to whom they owed their jobs; Connecticut’s Roger Sherman agreed. So the framers came up canada goose with a solution: They assigned the impeachment cheap canada goose uk power to the House and the power to try impeachments to the Senate. canada goose outlet uk

canada goose outlet reviews To the Supreme Court, the framers reserved an almost exclusively ceremonial role in impeachment, assigning the chief justice to preside over the president’s trial in the Senate. Of his limited role in President Bill Clinton’s impeachment trial, then Chief Justice William Rehnquist later said, „I did nothing in particular, and I did it very well.” canada goose outlet reviews

canada goose outlet store The framers, however, did not anticipate two major changes to the court that Canada Goose Parka have given it a significant role in the impeachment process. The court has gone from what Alexander Hamilton famously called the „least dangerous” branch to being a muscular and often partisan powerhouse Canada Goose Outlet with the ability to halt a criminal investigation before the impeachment process has even begun. In addition, our increasingly broad and unwieldy law enforcement and investigative apparatus has given today’s Supreme Court many more canada goose clearance sale opportunities to supervise criminal investigations and prosecutions. canada goose canada goose coats on sale outlet store

canada goose outlet nyc As a result, with Judge Brett M. Kavanaugh’s confirmation hearings set to begin just as pressure to impeach President Trump palpably canada goose uk shop mounts, Canada Goose Jackets the framers’ attempt to guard against the court’s bias has failed. canada goose outlet nyc

canada goose outlet It’s true that three of Nixon’s appointees to the court voted against him in the famous Watergate tapes case; the fourth (Rehnquist) recused himself. Still, it’s hardly a stretch to think that, consciously or not, bias might incline a justice to rule in favor of the president who appointed him. Even more than Trump’s other exercises of his power, including his appointment of Justice Neil M. Gorsuch, confirming canada goose uk outlet Kavanaugh at this possible inflection point in the Trump presidency would have special historical significance. canada goose outlet

canada goose outlet sale Impeachment proceedings look more likely today than at any previous point in Trump’s presidency. Trump’s former longtime personal attorney pleaded guilty to two major felonies, which he said were committed at the president’s direction to influence the election. The sitting president is thus effectively an unindicted co conspirator in a secret plot to use hush money to tilt the 2016 election through deliberate commission of crimes. If a Justice Kavanaugh were to uk canada goose outlet cast a deciding vote in a case against Trump, it could determine the fate of his presidency and forever alter the nation’s future. The framers found such a vote worthy of special attention and designed the impeachment process specifically to avoid it. canada goose outlet sale

canada goose outlet online Trump is under credible threat of impeachment for crimes allegedly committed at his direction in service of his election. A special counsel is probing his campaign’s possible cooperation with a hostile foreign nation. As that storm and others rage, Trump has nominated an Article II maximalist to the Supreme Court a man who may well have Canada Goose Online been selected specifically for his antipathy to prosecution or even investigation of any sitting president. There is no need to hurry. The slowly mounting chorus of senators calling for canadian goose jacket a pause in Kavanaugh’s confirmation would have resonated strongly with the framers. Their views cannot rule us from the grave, but the structure they created has served us well canada goose outlet online.